model-writtenrun 3528 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Peter Eisentraut proposed automating RangeTblEntry jumbling and serialization and simplifying its mutator, while identifying inconsistent field-validity rules and possible serialization growth as unresolved issues #1.
- Matthias van de Meent supported reducing special cases and reported substantial size reductions from separate work on omitting default-valued fields, while leaving detailed review of these patches for later #2.
- Peter added generated Constraint read/write support because its hand-maintained implementations repeatedly fell out of sync; he considered the first three patches reviewable but kept RangeTblEntry serialization automation experimental #3.
- Paul A Jungwirth reported successful compilation and tests after each patch, suggested removing the obsolete union proposal and correcting field comments, and recommended delaying full serialization automation until default-value omission was available #4.
- Matthias warned that changing an entry's rtekind could leave stale fields that generic serialization would retain, proposing centralized cleanup; Peter suggested consistency assertions and proposed proceeding with the Constraint and jumbling patches #5 #6.
- The Constraint patch from #3 landed as fbc93b8b5f, with rebase adjustments for the intervening without_overlaps field.
- Peter returned with the remaining work split into smaller patches, including comment cleanups, corrected jumbling annotations, independent dump-order alignment, and experimental validity assertions; he limited the PG17 target to the first five patches and deferred walker/mutator simplification and full serialization automation pending progress on compact output #7.
- Andrew Dunstan reviewed the first five patches and said they looked good #8; the obsolete-comment removal, lateral-comment clarification, and comment reformatting from #7 landed unchanged apart from rebasing as 83d8065b1f, 1e1eb12c25, and d575051b9a.
- Generated RangeTblEntry jumbling from #7 landed with the same code changes as 367c989cd8, and dump-order alignment landed as b4080fa3dc with the planned catalog-version bump added.
- Peter confirmed committing the first five patches and closing the commitfest entry; the validity-assertion prototype, walker/mutator simplification, and full RangeTblEntry serialization automation remained uncommitted in this thread #9 #7.