model-writtenrun 3752 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Tristan Partin proposed a new --check mode combining diff output with failure status for CI, initially making it mutually exclusive with the existing modes #1.
- Daniel Gustafsson suggested git-style exit-code semantics, Michael Banck favored the clearer --check name, and Euler Taveira and Tom Lane questioned the growing set of conflicting options #3 #4 #5 #6.
- Tristan accepted changing the interface, Alvaro Herrera proposed renaming --silent-diff to --check, and Andrew Dunstan supported the direction while clarifying that displaying diffs must remain non-destructive #7 #8 #9.
- Tristan replaced the initial design with combinable --check and --diff options, then corrected a duplicated condition reported by Jelte Fennema-Nio and stale variable references #10 #11 #12.
- Daniel judged the revised approach nearly ready, squashed the patches, and updated the manual; he also identified the wiki update, while Euler pointed out the buildfarm client's dependency on the old option names #13 #14.
- Jelte requested that --check --diff show every failing file before returning status 2, and Tristan added status accumulation to implement that behavior #18 #19 #22.
- Jelte also proposed --write for pre-commit workflows, but Tristan questioned combining checking and writing, Andrew treated it as a separate topic, and Daniel favored the existing two-patch compromise to avoid complicating the interface #21 #23 #24 #25.
- Jelte extended the series with --write and restored early exit when checking without either writing or displaying diffs; Tristan accepted the early-exit point and said the patch looked good #27 #28.
- Tristan prepared a buildfarm client change and obtained wiki access, and Andrew explained that he could coordinate the core change with the affected buildfarm animal he operated #26 #29.
- Andrew committed 387aecc948 from #22, adding a one-line check-only early exit; his announcement confirmed that the earlier compromise had consensus, leaving --write out #30.
- The thread ended with the option changes landed and Jelte reporting a working pre-commit solution and an updated wiki hook; no further pursuit of --write appears in the thread #31.