model-writtenrun 3024 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- David Benjamin proposed replacing the mixture of PostgreSQL custom BIO callbacks and OpenSSL socket callbacks with an independent custom BIO, restoring BIO_get_data/BIO_set_data and reporting successful SSL tests in #1.
- Daniel Gustafsson questioned whether BIO_CTRL_FLUSH could always succeed in #2; David explained in #3 that this BIO has no intermediate buffer and rejected writes do not create anything to flush, so the no-op implementation remained.
- Andres Freund supported the separation but questioned EOF handling, descriptor flags, control return values, and helper names in #6; David incorporated EOF tracking, removed BIO_TYPE_DESCRIPTOR, and renamed helpers around Port and PGconn in #7.
- Review slowed during the PostgreSQL 17 feature freeze, as Daniel explained in #9, and David subsequently rebased over ALPN changes in #11.
- Peter Eisentraut warned that dropping older OpenSSL support would obsolete the new configuration checks in #12; Daniel later supplied a rebase removing those compatibility provisions in #14.
- Daniel supplied the complete patch plus a separate cleanup removing redundant OpenSSL error-queue entries in #15; David approved the cleanup and explained why BIO_TYPE_DESCRIPTOR should stay unset in #16, and Daniel agreed to retain only BIO_TYPE_SOURCE_SINK in #17.
- Daniel committed both parts of #15 together as 6f782a2a17, with a rewritten commit message and whitespace cleanup but no further code changes, and reported testing across multiple OpenSSL and LibreSSL versions in #18.
- David asked about backpatching because future OpenSSL changes could expose the remaining release-branch risk in #19; Tom Lane opposed an immediate backpatch pending more testing in #20, and Daniel agreed in #21, leaving the work landed on the development branch with backpatching deferred.