model-writtenrun 7084 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Heikki Linnakangas proposed replacing guessable 32-bit cancellation tokens with 256-bit keys and a variable-length wire representation in #1, initially using an optional protocol feature and moving key generation from the postmaster into backends.
- Jelte Fennema-Nio and Peter Eisentraut favored a minor protocol-version bump in #2 and #3; Heikki adopted version 3.1, added explicit key-length fields and documentation, and incorporated signaling and parsing feedback in #8.
- Jelte reversed his preference for explicit key-length fields in #9, favoring reuse of the existing cancellation message and requesting a compatibility option, while Robert Haas warned about middleware breakage in #10.
- Heikki separated the backend-generation refactoring from the protocol work in #11 and #12, moving cancellation keys into the existing ProcSignal array instead of PMSignalState.
- Jelte identified concurrency concerns and recommended spinlocks in #15; meanwhile, Tomas Vondra's proposal to target individual queries rather than backends in #16 was deferred by Jelte in #17 to keep this work focused on key length.
- Heikki added per-slot spinlocks in #18 and landed the refactoring as 9d9b9d46f3, adding EXEC_BACKEND pointer propagation and process-group signaling before committing, as explained in #19.
- Thomas Munro cautioned in #20 that Windows can recycle PIDs immediately, reinforcing the value of longer keys without requesting another change to the completed refactoring.
- Heikki resumed the longer-key work in #21, introducing an OpenBSD-derived timingsafe_bcmp(), a protocol_version connection option, and variable-length CancelRequest payloads, although BackendKeyData still retained an explicit length field.
- Robert requested alignment with the parallel protocol work and separation of the version bump from cancellation changes in #22 and #24; Heikki agreed to merge the overlapping infrastructure in #25.
- Jacob Champion questioned the portable comparison's timing guarantees in #27, leading Jelte to propose using OpenSSL's CRYPTO_memcmp in #30; converting psql to encrypted cancellation was explicitly left for separate work in that same message.
- After the long gap, Jelte combined the protocol infrastructure from thread #48977 and cancellation work in #33, removing BackendKeyData's explicit length field, adding the OpenSSL implementation, and selecting protocol 3.2 because older PgBouncer versions incorrectly advertised support for 3.1.
- Robert committed the two independent fixes from #33 unchanged as c9d94ea215 for the Windows export and e87c14b19e for negotiation-message tracing, announcing both in #34.
- Jelte clarified in #35 that libpq would continue requesting protocol 3.0 by default and require explicit connection settings to use 3.2, addressing Robert's compatibility concern acknowledged in #36.
- Heikki posted the remaining series in #37, fixing negotiation diagnostics, rejecting duplicate negotiation messages, documenting the 256-byte key limit, and adding protocol documentation sections while retaining the conservative client default.
- The timingsafe_bcmp attachment from #37 landed unchanged as 09be391126, and its message-length documentation correction landed with wording edits as 85d799ba8a.
- Jelte's negotiation work from #37 landed with state-flag and error-reporting cleanups as 5070349102, while the connection options and protocol-3.2 bump were combined with a simpler version parser and revised tests in 285613c60a; this submission is the latest matching source for both commits, superseding the earlier source attribution in thread #48977.
- The longer-key attachment from #37 landed as a460251f0a, correcting the protocol threshold and documenting 32-byte server keys within the 256-byte wire limit, including room for layered middleware.
- The protocol-version section and table from #37 landed with editorial adjustments as b05751220b, and Heikki announced completion of the series in #38.
- Daniel Gustafsson found the missing pg_config.h.in declarations and attached a fix in #39; Heikki approved it in the thread's final message #40, and it subsequently landed unchanged as b82e7eddb0, completing the submitted work while protocol 3.0 remained libpq's default.