model-writtenrun 7090 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
May 2024 · 1 entry
- Jacob Champion proposed exposing authenticating backends in pg_stat_activity after a hung PAM connection pinned xmin and affected replicas; his initial series also experimented with wait events around external authentication calls #1.
Jun - Jul 2024 · 1 entry
- Noah Misch supported the visibility improvement and requested reporting before locks or snapshots #2; Jacob added injection-point tests and BackgroundPsql prerequisites in #3, then moved reporting immediately after process registration while shelving xmin release because its catalog-snapshot invariants were unclear #5.
Aug - Sep 2024 · 2 entries
- Andrew Dunstan endorsed the empty-result prerequisite #6, while Michael Paquier endorsed asynchronous connections and suggested replacing the misleading authenticating state with a general startup state #7.
- Michael requested a dedicated authentication wait class and finer event names #9; Noah initially preferred aggregation-friendly names, Robert Haas argued that distinct names aid diagnosis, and Noah withdrew his objection #10 #14 #17.
Nov 2024 · 7 entries
- Jacob's next series introduced STATE_STARTING, documentation, and an Auth wait class with more specific events, but retained repeated backend-status initialization while explaining his concerns about splitting it #18.
- Michael committed the asynchronous-connection prerequisite as ba08edb065 and the empty-result fix as 70291a3c66, taking those components from #18 with documentation, comment, and formatting edits #20.
- Jacob resent the two remaining features with injection-point installation checks and a more specific test filename after Michael's review #21.
- Andres Freund objected to initializing backend status twice and to broad wait-event regions that could include PostgreSQL execution or nested waits; his explanation persuaded Jacob to split initialization and narrow instrumentation #22 #28 #29.
- Jacob moved instrumentation down to specific library calls and RADIUS syscalls, retaining one name for the two TranslateName calls and adding a separate LDAP-unbind wrapper patch #30.
- Jacob then rewrote status reporting into initial, security, and final phases, updated auxiliary processes, and added tests for SSL details visible before authentication #31.
- Andres backported the two previously committed test-infrastructure changes as 31a242e90c and 49b6f4a02b, preserving their implementations from #18 to reduce cross-branch differences before further BackgroundPsql fixes; the backport discussion in thread #51068 confirms this thread as their implementation source.
Feb - Mar 2025 · 12 entries
- Review resumed after a winter gap when Michael found the SSL test ineffective and questioned repeated security reporting #32; Jacob fixed regex escaping and backend selection and reluctantly expanded LDAP unbind into nine separately named wait sites #34.
- Michael questioned exposing peer-certificate fields before authentication, while Jacob argued that verified transport identities should already be trustworthy; they agreed to proceed with only post-authentication security reporting #35 #36 #37 #38.
- Jacob removed the early security-reporting call and associated SSL tests #39, and Michael prepared the standalone startup-reporting patch with comment cleanup #40.
- Michael committed startup reporting as c76db55c90, making only light comment and TODO edits to #40, then reposted the uncommitted wait-event remainder #41.
- Andres reported Windows CI failures in the new pre-authentication test #43, and Jacob reproduced the race by delaying execution between publishing the starting state and reaching the injection point #45.
- Michael supplied a fix requiring the injection-point wait event before wakeup #46, and Jacob reposted it with an additional client-backend restriction to avoid selecting unrelated processes #48.
- Andres questioned open-coded polling loops, then acknowledged that the existing session timeout already bounded them #49 #51; Michael nevertheless proposed a reusable BackgroundPsql polling helper #52.
- Jacob demonstrated confusing timeout behavior in the helper proposal #53, so Michael deferred that API and committed the exact combined simpler fix from #48 as e2080261cc, retaining both wait-event and client-backend checks #54.
- Jacob restored the unchanged wait-event remainder for CI #55, but Andres continued to oppose broad library-call instrumentation, distinguishing acceptable syscall waits from code regions with callback, nesting, interruptibility, and error-recovery hazards #56 #58.
- Jacob recognized that PAM callbacks could reenter PostgreSQL and encounter unsafe error handling #60, while Andres favored making authentication methods nonblocking and emphasized the existing timeout and shutdown problems #62 #64.
- Jacob withdrew the remaining wait-event work after finding that pgstat_report_activity() also needed changes to work safely during backend initialization #65.
- At the thread's end, the test infrastructure, early starting-state visibility, and race fix remained committed, while authentication wait events and the polling helper remained uncommitted; Michael accepted the withdrawal and suggested future tracking of the HBA or ident entry associated with a backend #54 #66.