model-writtenrun 3026 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Nathan Bossart opened the thread with an asynchronous-libpq prototype for retrieving relation and replication information, reporting that a 10,000-database upgrade fell from roughly fourteen minutes to eleven minutes in his test #1.
- Jeff Davis questioned the complexity tradeoff and suggested reusing connections for multiple queries #2; Nathan explained that threads would require additional machinery and that parallelization could complement query consolidation #3.
- After a six-week gap, Nathan replaced the specialized prototype with a reusable callback framework and initial conversions for subscription checks, relation information, loadable libraries, and extension updates #4; Robert Haas endorsed asynchronous communication, and Nathan clarified that the framework waited with select() #5 #6.
- Nathan added data-type checks and five further compatibility checks while preserving the callback architecture #7 #8; he left harder conversions and further consolidation outside the series because they offered little measured benefit or mainly affected old server versions #8.
- Daniel Gustafsson requested simpler error handling, clearer query ownership, named result columns, and expandable query buffers #9; Nathan then recognized that removing per-database subscription counting would permit one reusable query string per task step #12.
- The resulting series incorporated those improvements and temporarily included a subscription-count optimization developed in another thread as a prerequisite #13.
- Following Daniel's recommendation to land the independent live_check refactoring first #11, Nathan posted its corrected standalone version #14, Daniel approved it #15, and it landed unchanged in code as 4b56bb4ab4, confirmed in #16.
- Ilya Gladyshev tested the remaining work on 1,000 empty databases, reported a speedup from thirty-three to eight seconds for the checks, and suggested immediately starting another connection when a slot became free #17; Nathan incorporated that optimization into the rebased remainder and documented the framework #19.
- Ilya then proposed accepting query strings directly and identified broken data-type failure reporting and unnecessary global state #20; Nathan implemented those changes while explaining that retaining connections to every database would create scalability and max_connections concerns #21.
- Corey Huinker advocated pipelining to avoid delays between task steps #22 #24; Nathan instead combined each task's queries into one PQsendQuery call and made secure search_path setup an implicit first step, simplifying the code despite seeing no measurable speedup #26 #27.
- Nathan polished names, comments, and report-state handling, renamed the framework to task.c and UpgradeTask, and targeted the September commitfest for landing #28.
- Ilya's review identified missing select error handling, redundant result retrieval and polling, and incomplete --jobs documentation #29; Nathan discovered a deeper connection-establishment issue and added explicit readiness and read/write tracking in the next revision #30.
- Nathan moved the combined query buffer into UpgradeTask so it was built once #31; Ilya approved that version and supplied an inline simplification moving polling back into process_slot #32, which Nathan incorporated while removing skip_wait and simplifying wait_on_slots #33.
- Daniel read and tested the final series, endorsed landing, and spotted a comment typo #34; he and Nathan agreed that graceful connection cleanup on errors should remain a follow-up rather than delay this work #35 #36.
- The framework from #33 landed as 40e2e5e92b with light comment and cleanup edits.
- The relation-and-logical-slot conversion from #33 landed as 6d3d2e8e54 with a redundant query semicolon removed, while the subscription-state conversion landed unchanged in code as 7baa36de58.
- The loadable-library conversion from #33 landed as 46cad8b319 with a redundant query semicolon removed, and extension-update retrieval landed unchanged in code as 6ab8f27bc7.
- The data-type and contrib/isn conversions from #33 landed unchanged in code as bbf83cab98 and 9db3018cf8.
- The postfix-operator conversion from #33 landed unchanged in code as c34eabfbbf, while the polymorphics conversion landed as cf2f82a37c with a redundant query semicolon removed.
- The WITH OIDS and encoding-conversion checks from #33 landed unchanged in code as f93f5f7b98 and c880cf2588.
- Nathan's final message confirmed that the remaining series had been committed #37; all submitted parallelization patches had landed, with graceful error cleanup and any further task consolidation left as possible follow-up work.