model-writtenrun 2907 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Peter Eisentraut proposed eliminating strtok() in #1, using strsep() where adjacent delimiters should produce empty fields and strtok_r() where whitespace should collapse, with separate portability patches for both functions.
- Ranier Vilela suggested const-qualified tokens and an alternative strsep() implementation in #2, while Kyotaro Horiguchi validated the semantic distinction, reported successful Linux tests and an MSVC build, and raised a Cygwin portability question in #3.
- Peter rejected const-qualified tokens because C23 strchr() would preserve constness despite subsequent writes, and retained the OpenBSD implementation to share an upstream source with existing string replacements in #4.
- Tom Lane proposed strpbrk() in #5, supported by Michael Paquier's portability observation in #6, but Peter preferred strsep()'s simpler tokenization interface in #7, and David Steele endorsed that choice and the series in #8.
- The original strsep() portability and conversion patches from #1 landed unchanged apart from rebasing as 683be87fbb and 5d2e1cc117 on July 22.
- The Windows mapping and timezone-parser conversion from #1 landed unchanged as 4d130b2872 and 65504b747f on July 23, and Peter announced completion in #9.
- Alexander Lakhin reopened the thread with a malformed SCRAM secret that crashed parsing in #10; Ranier diagnosed strsep()'s advanced-pointer semantics and supplied a tested fix in #11.
- Peter simplified the SCRAM correction to check only the advanced pointer in #12; Ranier questioned removing the return-value checks but remained neutral and identified himself as a reviewer in #13.
- Alexander found that the logging conversion lost the allocation pointer before free() in #14, prompting Peter's separate patch in #16 to preserve allocation pointers in both logging.c and pg_regress.c.
- Ranier proposed an additional logging-loop condition in #15 and defended it in #18, but Peter rejected it in #17, Alexander demonstrated that it broke color output while Peter's fix worked in #19, and Ranier withdrew it after reporting a Windows test in #20.
- Peter committed the SCRAM fix from #12 unchanged as 24a36f91e3 and the memory-leak fix from #16 unchanged as 4b652692e9 on October 18.
- Peter announced both fixes committed in #21, and Ranier closed with thanks in #22; all four original patches and both follow-up fixes had landed, with no further patch pending.