model-writtenrun 2979 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
Jul - Oct 2024 ยท 17 entries
- Marcos Pegoraro requested links from terse release-note entries to their supporting discussions or code, and Daniel Gustafsson explained that commit identifiers already existed in otherwise hidden SGML comments #1 #2.
- Robert Haas and Masahiko Sawada supported exposing those links, while Tom Lane highlighted the need to handle multiple commits per entry #7 #9 #8.
- When jian he proposed prefixed links, Marcos Pegoraro and Daniel Gustafsson preferred placing them after each entry; Daniel and Euler Taveira favored linking to commits because commit messages provide a route to the discussion #11 #12 #13 #14.
- Jian's first patch added visible GitHub links for PostgreSQL 17; Robert Haas defended displaying hashes, Euler Taveira requested project-controlled URLs, and Andres Freund suggested an SGML variable for their base domain #15 #17 #18 #19.
- Jian adopted postgr.es URLs and the commit_baseurl entity, then corrected spacing, punctuation, and bracket grouping in response to Marcos's reviews, culminating in Marcos's approval #20 #21 #22 #23 #24 #25.
- Bruce Momjian proposed automating extraction from SGML comments, Tom Lane wanted coverage of older release notes, and Peter Eisentraut explained the difficulties of deriving website annotations from XML comments #26 #28 #32.
- With PostgreSQL 17's release approaching, Jelte Fennema-Nio urged landing the manual work first; Jian refreshed and proofread the patch, and Marcos verified that every link worked and matched its release-note item #34 #35 #36.
- Bruce agreed to land Jian's completed PostgreSQL 17 work, and 9f949c9cb2 exactly matches the final attachment #38 #35.
- Bruce subsequently announced a presentation using section symbols instead of hashes, brackets, and added periods, explaining that hashes seemed unnecessarily complex for ordinary readers; Marcos accepted the landing while noting the usefulness of distinguishable links #39 #40 #41 #42.
- Bruce supplied a Perl script to generate commit links and reported testing it against PostgreSQL 12 through 17; 63357b6c7f added that automation and release-process instructions, while 81978404a3 added generated links to the older release notes #43 #44.
- Marcos, Alvaro Herrera, and Jelte suggested numbered or superscript alternatives to repeated section symbols; Bruce instead proposed an explanatory paragraph at the start of the release-notes appendix while leaving alternative labeling open #45 #47 #48 #50.
- Tom Lane reported poor PDF rendering, which Bruce confirmed; Peter Eisentraut questioned making this change between release candidate and general availability, and Alvaro recommended specialized XSLT handling or reverting the feature #51 #52 #53 #54.
- Jelte proposed preserving HTML links while hiding them in PDF, and Tom characterized the annotations as an experiment that could be adjusted without compatibility constraints #56 #62.
- Bruce implemented PDF suppression in 67ffd2eb52 and posted the matching already-applied patch, removing both the section symbols and their footnotes from print output #63.
- Bruce revised the explanatory paragraph to disappear from print output as well, committed it as 923241acb1, and posted the exact applied version #50 #64.
- In October, Bruce reopened the symbol choice because PDF suppression removed its character-set constraint; Greg Sabino Mullane suggested a scroll, but Tom warned about font support and oversized emoji, leading Bruce to retain the section symbol #65 #66 #68 #69.
- All supplied implementation patches had landed by the thread's end, with no revert reported; symbol selection remained a discussion topic as Jacob Champion suggested plus-minus and Nathan Bossart ended by proposing delta, without a replacement patch or decision adopting either #70 #71 #72 #73 #74.