model-writtenrun 2383 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Mark Dilger proposed removing index-AM layering violations in #1, using shallow hash/btree clones and a deep btree clone with rotated strategy numbers to expose assumptions in core code; the test modules were diagnostic infrastructure rather than promised production additions.
- Alexandra Wang tested the series and supplied build fixes in #6; Mark incorporated them with consistent module versioning and improved expected-output translation in #7, while Andrew Dunstan added handling for alternative expected files in #10.
- Peter Eisentraut proposed a more general tree-height callback name in #8, and Mark discussed potentially returning richer cost-estimation data in #9; Peter kept the integer interface, added a wrapper and documentation in #11, and committed it with a compiler-warning fix as 56fead44dc.
- Alexandra identified a missing amcancrosscompare flag in the xtree test module in #13, after which its remaining regression differences matched treeb and concerned plans rather than query results.
- Peter reviewed replacing strategy-number encodings of sort direction with booleans in #15 and announced the landings in #17: SortGroupClause gained reverse_sort in 0d2aa4d493, and MergeJoin gained mergeReversals in c594f1ad2b.
- Peter laid out alternatives for communicating operator semantics in #18; Mark argued in #19 for mapping to the existing comparison enum rather than imposing btree numbering or importing every spatial strategy without defined core semantics.
- After a gap, Andrew supplied the rebased archived series in #22; Peter accepted the mapping approach but requested the CompareType name, one invalid sentinel, and proper GiST integration in #23, with Mark agreeing to those simplifications in #24.
- During that cleanup, 63e10988f8 corrected an nbtutils.c error message that called a strategy number a RowCompareType; this small thread-linked change has no matching indexed attachment.
- Peter posted the enum rename and GiST conversion in #25; Paul A Jungwirth assessed their temporal-key and replication implications in #26, while raising broader questions about intersection operators, uniqueness capabilities and opclass updates that this series did not resolve.
- Peter landed the rename unchanged as 6339f6468e and the GiST conversion with an additional replication caller update as 630f9a43ce, announcing both in #27; Nathan Bossart then reported a C++ header-check problem in #28, which Peter acknowledged fixing in #29.
- Peter's integration series in #30 connected GiST mapping to the generic AM callbacks and used opfamily plus input type instead of opclass; its preparatory rename landed as a5709b5bb2, and its helper plus callers were combined as 43493cceda.
- The same submission #30 supplied the separate comparison header and translation callbacks, committed as 119fc30dd5 and c09e5a6a01, with a copyright update and COMPARE_INVALID moved into the callback commit.
- Mark objected to the remaining hardcoded GiST OID and supplied an inline alternative in #31; Peter instead derived the AM from the existing opclass argument, explained that choice in #32, and landed the integration as 622f678c10.
- Peter extracted foreign-key and speculative-insertion support in #33, explaining that uniqueness was already established and only strategy lookup needed generalization; both attached patches landed unchanged as bfe21b760e and b92c03342d.
- Finding opcintype unnecessary and difficult to obtain consistently, Peter proposed any/any registration for GiST translation functions in #34; both patches were combined, with a catalog-version bump, into 7d6d2c4bbd.
- Peter reposted the remaining main series in #35, explicitly excluding test scaffolding from intended commits and setting CLUSTER support aside because it needed a different approach; its capability-flag patch landed with comment and documentation refinements as ce62f2f2a0.
- After Mark rebased the main series again in #36, Peter replaced the sortsupport strategy conversion with a direct boolean argument in #37, which landed unchanged as a359d37019.
- Peter extracted opfamily helpers and support for non-btree unique indexes on partition keys and materialized views in #38; Tom Lane questioned unexpected helper errors in #39, and Mark identified a potentially brittle assertion in the partition-key path in #40.
- Peter combined the helper patches and made missing mappings return InvalidOid in 7317e64126, moved the partition-key error check in f278e1fe30, and landed the materialized-view patch unchanged as 9d6db8bec1, confirming the review-driven adjustments in #42 and #43.
- The related cleanup 190dc27998 removed an obsolete claim that only btree could provide uniqueness, while preserving the separate btree restriction needed for reliable ADD CONSTRAINT USING INDEX upgrades.
- Peter substantially reduced the remaining scope in #44, removing unfinished non-btree ordering-family and type-cache generalizations, postponing row-comparison, range-type and ALTER OPERATOR FAMILY work, and consolidating the main code around CompareType instead of parallel strategy-number interfaces.
- Mark reported successful regression, recovery, upgrade and treeb testing in #45 and supplied a missing-argument fix; the separately extracted network-support patch from #44 landed unchanged as be1cc9aaf5.
- Peter posted only the remaining central conversion in #46, incorporating the argument fix and retaining built-in-AM shortcuts after performance testing showed get_mergejoin_opfamilies() was sensitive to added lookup costs.
- The final submission #46 was split into a PathKey conversion with interface adaptations in 8123e91f5a and an unchanged variable-range subset in 9ef1851685.
- Andres Freund reported buildfarm crashes from a null read in get_actual_variable_range() in #47, and Peter said a fix was on its way in the last supplied message #48; the supplied candidates contain no separate repair commit, so that repair cannot be verified here.
- The candidate history extends beyond the last supplied message: a8025f5448 subsequently landed the remaining ordering and predicate-planning work from #46, with factored performance shortcuts and revised translation calls; the test scaffolding and features explicitly postponed in #44 remain outside these landings.