model-writtenrun 2072 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Amit Langote proposed specialized sequential-scan functions selected by qualification, projection, and EvalPlanQual requirements, using a local inline copy of scan logic; Junwang Zhao's benchmarks showed improvements of up to about 5% #1.
- David Rowley reproduced nearly 5% improvement on TPC-H Q1 but found duplicated maintenance-sensitive code and a missing interrupt check, so he supplied a shared inline implementation and recommended retaining an external ExecScan interface for extensions #2.
- Amit adopted David's architecture, moved the helpers into execScan.h, retained external ExecScan, and added an experimental second patch splitting the inline implementation further to avoid non-null checks #3.
- David approved the main patch subject to minor fixes and asked for evidence that the experimental split helped; Amit incorporated the fixes but found no consistent additional gain from the split, which disappeared from the next submission #4 #5 #8 #9.
- Vladlen Popolitov questioned how additional branches could improve performance, prompting David to explain initialization-time selection and Amit to document it; Amit later supplied reproducible benchmarks showing why disabling Gather exposed the benefit of avoiding projection work #6 #7 #9 #10 #14.
- Junwang compared generated function sizes and identified a declaration alignment issue, while his suggestion to rename es_epq_active was deferred to a separate discussion #11 #13 #15.
- Amit finalized the commit explanation in #16 and landed the refactor as fb9f955025 with only comment and formatting edits, announcing the push in #17; adapting other scan nodes remained future work.
- Months later, Andres Freund found that specialized functions still tested pointers known to be non-null and proposed pg_assume(), reporting roughly 13% smaller nodeSeqscan object code and a small repeatable performance gain #18.
- Amit endorsed the pg_assume() patch and discussed its explanatory comment with Andres, ultimately accepting the original wording #19 #20 #21 #23 #26.
- A separate proposal to omit ResetExprContext() encountered ForeignNext() as a counterexample, leading to discussion of cheaper MemoryContextReset() handling that would account for child contexts; Amit's local experiment passed check-world but did not establish that skipping child cleanup was safe #18 #19 #20 #21 #23 #26.
- Nikita Malakhov suggested sequential-scan scan keys, but Andres explained locking hazards, expression restrictions, and possible extra deformation costs; Nikita confirmed that his own experiment was expensive #22 #24 #25.
- Andres landed #18 unchanged as b227b0bb4e and announced completion in #27, leaving both main optimizations committed while the memory-context optimization remained exploratory.