model-writtenrun 2235 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Shaik Mohammad Mujeeb proposed documenting the unsigned-to-signed query-ID assignment in pg_stat_statements in #1; Ilia Evdokimov and Michael Paquier questioned the comment's value in #2 and #5, while Shaik defended explaining the apparent overflow in #6.
- Junwang Zhao explained that the conversion loses no information in #7, and Peter Eisentraut identified signedness warnings in logging code and suggested either centralizing output conversion or storing signed query IDs internally in #8.
- David Rowley adopted the internal int64 approach in #10, replacing the original comment-only proposal with changes across core and pg_stat_statements, initially suggesting that the cleanup could wait for PostgreSQL 19.
- Michael Paquier argued that newly introduced plan IDs justified changing both identifiers for PostgreSQL 18 in #11, Lukas Fittl supported avoiding future extension compatibility casts in #12, and David agreed with acting sooner in #14.
- Julien Rouhaud proposed retaining unsigned identifiers and adding an unsigned SQL type in #15, but David considered that broader work too late for PostgreSQL 18 in #17, and Michael discussed its casting and usability difficulties in #19.
- Michael posted David's unchanged query-ID patch together with his own plan-ID conversion in #16, establishing the two-patch series.
- Sami Imseih found an overlooked saved_queryId variable and requested clearer documentation of signed hash extraction in #18; Michael corrected the variable and added comments in #20, declining a new macro for just two call sites.
- Peter suggested a QueryId typedef in #22, but David and Michael questioned its benefit because constants, Datum conversions, hashing, and generated node support would still need separate attention in #23 and #24; the typedef was not included.
- After Michael sought release-team agreement during beta in #25, Nathan Bossart reported reviewing the latest series and saw no strong reason to object to PostgreSQL 18 inclusion in #26, allowing Michael and David to proceed in #27 and #28.
- David committed the query-ID portion of #20 as c3eda50b06, moving the signedness explanation from queryjumblefuncs.c to the Query structure as explained in #29, and confirmed completion in #30.
- Michael committed the unchanged plan-ID portion of #20 as e050af2868 and closed the open item in #32, leaving both conversions landed and the original comment-only proposal superseded.