model-writtenrun 2103 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Evgeniy Gorbanev reported missing Zstd read-error handling and proposed returning false whenever fread returned zero #1; Daniel Gustafsson explained that this also catches normal EOF, and Evgeniy confirmed test failures after enabling Zstd support #2 #4 #7.
- Tom Lane identified contradictions between the documented read_func contract and its callers, including their mistaken use of an always-true return value to detect EOF #8 #10; Daniel supplied a localized patch that checked ferror and made callers inspect the byte count #11.
- Tom expanded the repair into a compression API redesign after finding that _ReadBuf missed premature EOF and Zstd_getc read a byte into an uninitialized int, making read_func return its byte count directly and proposing write-or-die semantics for writes #12.
- Tomas Vondra raised backbranch ABI concerns, and Tom concluded that changing this internal pg_dump/pg_restore API was safe to backpatch #14 #15.
- After exchanging patches off-list with Tomas, Daniel posted a six-part series incorporating Tom's patch and extending error handling across reading, writing, opening, closing, and initialization; changes considered PostgreSQL 19 material and additional error-path tests were left out #17.
- Tom's review found missing ENOSPC fallbacks and an inaccurate write_func comment #18; Daniel restored the fallbacks and briefly made writes return a byte count, then restored void after Tom argued that it would expose outdated callers at compile time #19 #20 #21.
- Daniel consolidated the series into one patch and reported successful tests on PostgreSQL 16 and 17 #22; when Tomas asked about coverage, Daniel explained that getc implementations and fault-dependent error paths remained insufficiently tested, leaving coverage improvements for a later cycle #23 #24.
- Tom identified wording errors in the consolidated patch, and Daniel corrected the comments, error message, and commit description in the final attachment #25 #26.
- After an August lull, Tom reviewed the final attachment again and said it looked good, and Daniel agreed to push it #27 #28.
- Daniel committed #26 as ec017a305b with only rebase and whitespace differences, backpatched the change through PostgreSQL 16, and confirmed completion in the thread's final message #29.