model-writtenrun 1776 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Tom Lane proposed adding lock mode and numeric object identifiers to lock-wait error context in #1, addressing difficult-to-diagnose timeouts while avoiding additional lock acquisitions to resolve object names.
- Zhang Mingli questioned whether the callback stack needed explicit restoration on the exception path in #2; Tom explained that the surrounding PG_TRY mechanism handles restoration in #3, and Zhang approved the patch in #4.
- Dilip Kumar supported numeric identifiers and avoiding catalog lookups in the error callback in #5 and #7; Tom reaffirmed that design and announced the unchanged patch's landing as f727b63e81 in #8.
- Andres Freund reported a Valgrind leak from the new callback in #9 and supplied a reproduction in #11, explaining that informational messages do not trigger the error cleanup that would reclaim the allocation.
- Tom proposed resetting ErrorContext after outermost non-error reporting in #12 and attached the generic cleanup patch in #13, reporting that check-world passed but an unrelated CREATE DATABASE failure blocked Valgrind testing.
- Andres supplied a temporary buffer-memory annotation workaround in #14, enabling Tom to confirm that the cleanup patch removed the reported leak and passed core regression tests under Valgrind in #15.
- Andres reviewed other ErrorContext uses, questioned whether explicit GUC cleanup calls remained necessary, and favored avoiding backpatch risk in #16; Tom initially agreed to remove those calls and defer backpatching in #17.
- In the final thread message, #18, Tom corrected that conclusion: GUC cleanup must remain because suppressed reports can bypass errfinish(), so he would clarify the comments instead.
- The cleanup patch from #13 subsequently landed as 89d57c1fb3, with its logic unchanged and five GUC comments clarified; both submitted changes landed on the development branch, while backpatching the cleanup was deferred unless field reports justified it.