model-writtenrun 1808 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- David Rowley opened the thread with #1, explaining that MSVC could not propagate a constant error level through ereport_domain()'s local variable and proposing a C11 _Generic predicate to expose the unconditional pg_unreachable() path.
- After Tom Lane requested confirmation in #2, David reported in #3 that removing a defensive return compiled without warnings under Visual Studio 2022 only with the macro change, and Tom supported proceeding in #4.
- Peter Eisentraut advocated adopting C11 across all platforms instead of adding an MSVC-specific language mode in #5; once that prerequisite landed, David rebased the patch without its build-system changes in #6, reporting correct branch elimination but no measurable pgbench improvement.
- Peter identified the _Generic implementation's integer-only limitation and requested clearer naming, documentation and guards in #7; David incorporated those changes in #8, and Tom explained the predicate suffix convention in #9, which David accepted in #10.
- David committed #8 as 59c2f03d1e and announced it in #12, omitting the temporary defensive-return removal while leaving broader removal of compiler-silencing code for future experience with other compilers.
- Peter reported successful CI testing and proposed dropping the misleading 'builtin' portion of the predicate name in #13; David approved in #14, and Peter landed the attachment unchanged as 8e2acda2b0, announcing completion in #15.
- Months later, Tom noticed that PLy_elog() still contained the old copied logic in #16; David confirmed the omission was accidental and agreed to the corresponding fix in #17.
- After David invited Tom to make the follow-up change in #19, Tom updated PLy_elog() without an attached patch as 017499a50f, backpatched it through PostgreSQL 19, and closed the thread with confirmation in #20; all submitted patches and the follow-up correction had landed.