model-writtenrun 7011 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Peter Eisentraut opened the thread with seven notational cleanup patches using C11's permission for identical repeated typedefs, explicitly leaving deeper header-dependency changes for later work #1.
- Tom Lane supported the approach, especially removing hbaPort and fmgr.h workarounds #2, while Chao Li reported a clean build and suggested corrected ExplainState comments and a ParamListInfo pointer typedef #3.
- Peter incorporated those corrections but declined scanner-type consolidation and YYSTYPE renaming because parser types differ and Bison requires the name #4; Chao then endorsed the revision #5.
- The pgbench prerequisite and scanner guard removal from #4 landed unchanged as separate commits 675ddc4d70 and ae0e1be9f2.
- The remaining components of #4 landed as the planner guard cleanup 1e3b5edb8e, ExplainState cleanup 70407d39b7, general forward declarations d4d1fc527b, hbaPort removal dc41d7415f and fmgr.h cleanup 4bd9191298, with only a planner-comment correction beyond the posted changes; Peter confirmed completion in #6.
- Alvaro Herrera extended the cleanup to more access-method and executor declarations in #7, beginning a new phase after Peter's series had landed.
- Alvaro then demonstrated that tuplesort.h was leaking BRIN dependencies into execnodes.h, proposed moving index instrumentation structs into another header, and supplied a separate inline idea for removing execnodes.h from replication/conflict.h #8.
- Tom called for a subsystem hierarchy governing header inclusion #9; Alvaro posted the complete conflict-header fix #10, which Tom judged sensible after an eyeball review #11.
- Peter identified implicit typedef dependencies in the additional declaration cleanup #12; Alvaro added the heapam.h TupleTableSlot declaration and preserved a genam.h comment before committing 81fc3e28e3, then announced the push #13.
- The conflict-header fix from #10 landed as 47da174524, using explicit struct declarations instead of the proposed repeated typedefs and supporting a PostgreSQL 18 backpatch; Alvaro confirmed the push in #14.
- Alvaro next proposed removing relcache.h and tidbitmap.h from genam.h #15, but Tom argued that headers need only compile themselves and that macro consumers should include their own dependencies #16, prompting Alvaro to move varatt.h includes into two C files #17.
- Alvaro reconsidered tidbitmap.h as a legitimate library dependency and instead removed its htup_details.h include while retaining the relcache.h cleanup #18; Tom endorsed both revised patches #19, and their combined changes landed unchanged in 3bf31dd243.
- The same discussion left broader header-layering policy and a possible ObjectType header split as future work, without attached implementations for those ideas #18 #19.
- Returning to the BRIN/Gin dependency problem, Alvaro introduced executor/instrument_node.h for index instrumentation and asked whether bitmap instrumentation should join it and whether genam.h should include it directly #20.
- Alvaro extended the series with removal of htup_details.h from tuptable.h #21, then added tupconvert.h and brin.h/gin.h cleanups and an inclusion-analysis script to quantify their benefits #22.
- The brin.h/gin.h cleanup from #22 landed as 1b6f61bd89, taking the gin_private.h include fix from the tuptable.h component and deferring the ginscan.c instrumentation include; the tuptable.h cleanup then landed as 1a8b5b11e4.
- At the thread's final message, Alvaro confirmed those two landings, abandoned the tupconvert.h patch in favor of eventually removing tupconvert.h from execnodes.h, and reposted the remaining tuplesort.h work with bitmap instrumentation plus a tentative broader consolidation patch #23.
- The instrumentation consolidation proposed in #23 continued in thread #52633, where Mario González Troncoso posted the later source patchset #610679 that led to 2defd00062 in January 2026, crediting Alvaro Herrera and Mario González as co-authors and explicitly deferring the remaining cross-header include removals.