model-writtenrun 1181 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Todd Lang reported that tailoring rules forced collation strength to tertiary and proposed choosing strength from the deterministic flag, after locally testing a hardcoded secondary strength #1.
- Daniel Verite explained that determinism does not prescribe strength and supplied a patch using UCOL_DEFAULT so strength settings inside rules take effect, while identifying lost locale attributes as a separate ICU bug #2; Todd endorsed this behavior and cited ICU's documentation correction #3.
- After Daniel registered the fix for review #4, Peter Eisentraut revisited it months later with a diagnostic patch showing that locale attributes were still lost and requested a test demonstrating the intended behavior #5.
- Daniel clarified that the patch fixes strength specified inside rules, not ICU's loss of locale attributes, and supplied a regression test proving that '[strength 1]' makes accented and unaccented strings compare equal #6.
- Peter committed Daniel's tested revision as 905e44152a, with only test formatting and comment cleanup, then asked whether to backpatch it #7.
- Daniel warned that backpatching could change existing collations whose previously ignored strength rules would become effective #8, and Peter decided against backpatching #9; the PostgreSQL fix landed, while the separate ICU locale-attribute issue remained unresolved.