model-writtenrun 1779 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Kevin K Biju reported that failures such as running out of disk space could leave state.tmp behind and block subsequent replication-slot saves, proposing O_TRUNC instead of O_EXCL in #1.
- Michael Paquier explained that earlier discussions had rejected O_TRUNC because O_EXCL provided protection, and supplied a replacement patch that removes the temporary file on four failure paths while holding the slot I/O lock in #2.
- Michael Paquier committed #2 unchanged as 912af1c7e9 and announced backpatching through PostgreSQL 13 in #3; he also reported successful crash-recovery cleanup checks and questioned whether an automated crash test justified its runtime.
- After the commit, Kevin K Biju endorsed the cleanup approach but raised the possibility that unlink itself could fail in #4; this response was too late to count as a pre-commit review.
- Michael Paquier replied that an unlink failure likely indicated broader problems that could cause a crash, after which recovery would clean up state.tmp, and considered the committed solution a reasonable balance in #5; no further patch or automated test was submitted.