model-writtenrun 529 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Nathan Bossart proposed percentage details, raising warning thresholds from 40M to 100M IDs, and server-only logging every million IDs below 500M remaining, aiming to convey urgency and give administrators more time to react #1.
- Chao Li reviewed the rebased series, questioning the percentage denominator and rounding and identifying typos; Nathan adopted equivalent ID-specific denominators, explained that the warning already supplies the exact count, and retained warnings regardless of unusually high autovacuum settings #3 #4.
- Shinya Kato approved the percentage feature, identified stale documentation examples, and questioned adding shared state and a modulo check to a hot path when administrators could already monitor database age; Nathan corrected the examples and abandoned periodic logging #5 #6.
- After wenhui qiu approved the final submission, Nathan committed its two components unchanged apart from rebase: percentage details as e646450e60 and 100M warning thresholds as 48f11bfa06, then confirmed completion #8 #6 #9.
- Fujii Masao reopened the thread with a wording correction because the percentage measures distance to wraparound, while ID allocation stops earlier, making 'available for use' misleading; Nathan agreed with the proposed clarification #10 #11.
- Fujii expanded the correction to standardize transaction-ID terminology in warning hints and test comments and added a separate documentation patch for outdated examples and prose, proposing backpatching the documentation correction to version 17 #12.
- Bharath Rupireddy preferred 'IDs remain' without 'space', and Fujii adopted that wording while retaining MultiXactId terminology for consistency with existing messages; broader multixact terminology cleanup was left outside this series #13 #14 #15 #16.
- Kyotaro Horiguchi argued that 'ID space' better identifies what the percentage measures, Nathan considered either wording clear, and Bharath accepted following the majority #17 #18 #19.
- Yugo Nagata favored retaining 'space' and questioned changing XID terminology in surrounding prose rather than example output; Fujii restored 'ID space', dropped the prose edit, and separated the warning-hint correction from the remaining error-example fix #20 #21.
- Bharath approved both final patches and reported that pgindent was satisfied; Fujii explained that backpatching the error-example correction was justified because the documentation contradicted actual runtime output, and Bharath accepted that explanation #22 #23 #24.
- Fujii committed the first component of #21 unchanged as dc6b6fe0a8, with backpatching through version 19, and the second unchanged as 034ff7f94a, with backpatching through version 17.
- Fujii's final message confirmed both corrections were pushed, leaving all retained work committed and the earlier periodic-logging proposal abandoned #25 #6.