model-writtenrun 411 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Jacob Champion announced plans to finish Jelte Fennema-Nio’s grease feature, testing unsupported minor versions and protocol extensions during PostgreSQL 19 beta, with an explicit max_protocol_version=3.0 escape hatch and a promised mid-beta revert #1.
- After reporting that the feature had landed, Jacob proposed directing grease failures to a wiki page that could offer more approachable, readily updated guidance and remain available after beta; Tom Lane supported the choice and suggested protecting the page #2 #3.
- Jacob created the wiki page and drafted separate guidance for users and developers, but removed a request to report failures back to PostgreSQL because the reporting destination and instructions were unclear #4 #5 #6.
- Jelte endorsed the wiki landing page subject to protection, and after Joe Conway arranged protection, Jacob committed the single-line diagnostic URL replacement as 2368c14e9e directly from the discussion #7 #9.
- Jelte subsequently proposed asking users to report upstream issues to pgsql-hackers with a [grease] subject tag so the project could assess readiness for future protocol changes; Jacob accepted the proposal and arranged the wiki update after discussion of possible mailing-list noise #10 #11 #12 #13 #14.
- After Beta 3, Jacob attached the planned revert and judged the campaign useful despite receiving no tagged reports, citing external issues and a Debian upgrade-wrapper problem; he also proposed developing a production implementation for PostgreSQL 20 #15.
- Jelte supported the revert but suggested retaining greasing on master; Jacob clarified that both master and the PostgreSQL 19 branch should revert because the original promise gave people reason to defer objections until a future proposal #16 #17.
- At the thread’s last message the revert was awaiting commitment, and it subsequently landed unchanged from #15 as 408a28c49a, with a PostgreSQL 19 backport; the reserved grease version and its documentation remain, while production greasing is left for future work.