model-writtenrun 1206 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Andres Freund opened the thread in #1 by identifying meaningless WAL-flush checks on fake LSNs from unlogged relations, arguing for future-proofing despite the currently harmless behavior and suggesting an assertion against impossible LSNs.
- Melanie Plageman supplied a broader cleanup in #2, introducing BufferNeedsWALFlush() and moving the check into StrategyRejectBuffer() to avoid unnecessary locking for unlogged buffers and non-bulkread strategies.
- Andres Freund challenged the helper’s local-buffer and hint-bit checks and its cross-file call sequence in #3; Melanie’s revision in #4 adopted his direct-call and existing-state suggestions and added the proposed LSN assertion, while explaining her preference for the original organization.
- After announcing plans to commit in #5, Melanie reconsidered whether the helper should support local buffers for future callers in #6.
- An intervening share-exclusive-lock change, 82467f627b, made the helper unnecessary, and Melanie reduced the patch to a BM_PERMANENT guard in #7; the additional XLogNeedsFlush() assertion was also omitted without an explanation in this thread.
- Melanie committed #7 as 11e0824bd9 with combined conditions, an explicit strategy-ring guard and expanded comments, then confirmed completion in #8, leaving no further patch pending in the thread.