model-writtenrun 8897 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- James Coleman reported a PostgreSQL 11.5 parallel hash join failing with an oversized DSA allocation in #1, and supplied a plan involving nearly six billion rows in #7.
- Tomas Vondra initially attributed the failure to unaccounted batch-management memory in #2, while Thomas Munro proposed an inline allocation-size guard in #4; discussion also raised planner accounting and fallback execution strategies in #6.
- Thomas explained that repeated repartitioning retained old temporary files in #11 and #14, while James's confirmation that the join key was unique undermined the suspected data-skew explanation in #18.
- Thomas identified exhausted hash bits in #19: bucket selection consumed 22 bits, leaving only ten for batches, so further batch growth could not distribute tuples as intended.
- The discussion weighed wider hashes, two separately computed hashes, and borrowing bucket bits: Tomas favored preserving batch splitting to respect work_mem in #23, while Andres noted that extended hash functions were optional in #26.
- Thomas posted a constant-mixing prototype in #28, but Tomas questioned its independence from bucket selection in #29, and Thomas explained why any replacement must preserve forward-only batch movement during growth in #32.
- Although Thomas's seven-billion-row test initially showed successful repartitioning in #35, further measurements revealed catastrophic bucket concentration, prompting the bit-reversal replacement in #36.
- Alvaro supported the helper placement and small performance cost in #37, and Tomas demonstrated that bit reversal completed a previously failing 4.5-billion-row join in #38, while also reporting ordinary-query overhead and a separate worker-shutdown hang.
- Tom Lane measured a repeatable parallel hash join slowdown with bit reversal in #41, although Tomas could not reproduce that magnitude in #42; Thomas then proposed rotation in #43 to preserve the old algorithm until bits ran out and reduce the machine-code change to a shift becoming a rotate.
- Tomas reproduced the separate shutdown hang and supplied worker backtraces in #47; Thomas suspected a latch reset without an interrupt check in #48, and Tomas's pending-interrupt values supported that diagnosis in #49.
- Thomas left the shutdown repair undecided between removing ResetLatch() and adding an interrupt check in #50, with no attached fix or resolution for that issue in the remaining thread.
- Thomas verified the rotation patch on the seven-billion-row join in #51; Tom requested a more specific helper name in #52, leading to the reusable pg_rotate_right32() version in #53.
- After Tom recommended BITS_PER_BYTE and removal of the extra header include in #54, Thomas committed #53 with those light edits and expanded explanatory comments as e69d644547, targeting all supported releases.
- Thomas confirmed the push in #55 and deferred wider hashing beyond PostgreSQL 13, leaving that improvement and the separately investigated shutdown hang outside the landed rotation fix.