model-writtenrun 1270 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Heikki Linnakangas opened the thread with explicit PGPROC cache-line alignment, questioned the padding cost of a power-of-two size, and suggested reorganizing fields or moving the subtransaction cache into a separate array, while requesting a concrete benchmark #5.
- Andres Freund supported explicit alignment to avoid difficult false-sharing problems and recommended grouping fields by access patterns, but cautioned that a separate subtransaction-cache array would increase connection-management copying costs #6.
- Bertrand Drouvot proposed an ordering that reduced PGPROC to 832 bytes and questioned the additional alignment padding; Andres explained that PG_CACHE_LINE_SIZE is 128 bytes and considered the extra memory small relative to other connection overheads #7 #8.
- Heikki expanded the submission into four patches, prioritizing readable field grouping, separating freelist and lock-wait links, and removing an unrelated redundant assignment discovered along the way #9.
- Bertrand endorsed the grouping and redundant-store fix, identified a missed PrintLockQueue() rename and stale ProcWakeup comment, and challenged the claim that alignment alone made PGPROC-number arithmetic cheaper #10.
- Heikki accepted the arithmetic correction and committed the redundant-store component unchanged as ab32a9e21d; Bertrand subsequently traced their differing structure-size measurements to LOCK_DEBUG changing LWLock's size #11 #12.
- Bertrand questioned whether alignment needed a padding-union fallback on unsupported compilers #13; Heikki later decided that omitting alignment was acceptable because it served performance rather than correctness #15.
- Heikki incorporated Bertrand's two missing-name corrections and committed the separate PGPROC links as 36bbcd5be3, then resubmitted the remaining reordering and alignment patches with revised comments and without performance benchmark results #14 #15.
- Bertrand questioned which remaining patch should introduce the typedef, but Heikki retained the submitted split and committed both diffs unchanged as 2e0853176f and 412f78c66e #16 #17.
- Peter Eisentraut recommended standard C11 alignas after the initial landing; Bertrand supplied a follow-up converting PGPROC and PgAioUringContext, reported unchanged padding, and included a separate, tentative ItemPointerData conversion #18 #19.
- Peter committed the PGPROC and PgAioUringContext conversion with a minor comment-formatting adjustment as 5c2a8d272b, while declining the ItemPointerData conversion as not worthwhile #20.
- Bertrand agreed to omit ItemPointerData and reported that the new commit was initially absent from repository mirrors; his final message confirmed that administrators had resolved that visibility problem, leaving the accepted work committed and the optional conversion dropped #21 #22.