model-writtenrun 1128 - may be wrong, links go to the source messages. Commit-by-commit LLM analysis is in the Commits dialog.
- Heikki Linnakangas proposed five cleanup patches in #1 because named-tranche terminology obscured the distinction between startup requests and dynamically registered tranches, and the existing metadata alternated between private and shared-memory representations.
- Nathan Bossart reviewed the series in #2, suggesting foreach_ptr loops, clearer allocation comments, possible atomic access to the tranche count, and reordering the final two patches to avoid introducing and immediately undoing conditional locking.
- Heikki retained spinlock protection rather than introducing an atomic counter, explained the startup locking assumptions, and accepted the reordering suggestion in #3.
- Sami Imseih supported the terminology cleanup but proposed renaming both public tranche APIs in #4; Heikki preferred preserving RequestNamedLWLockTranche() as a legacy interface while leaving a possible LWLockNewTrancheId() rename open in #5.
- The first three attachments from #1 landed as cc88481aeb, d6eba30a24, and 12e3e0f2c8, incorporating terminology edits, Nathan's loop cleanup, and minor comment corrections.
- The final two attachments from #1 landed in reversed order: 06d859aaf4 moved ShmemIndexLock into the allocator, then 30d432502b adopted ShmemInitStruct and removed both backend pointer transfers, avoiding the temporary conditional-locking scheme; Heikki announced the completed landing in #6.
- Sami identified stale comments after landing in #7 and supplied corrections in #8; Heikki committed them as 98993150c0, refining the initialization comment to distinguish built-in tranches from those requested through RequestNamedLWLockTranche(), as explained in #9.
- Sami supplied another comment cleanup in #10, removing the obsolete claim that MainLWLockArray required special transfer through BackendParameters in EXEC_BACKEND builds.
- Andres Freund reported a buildfarm pg_rewind failure in single-user mode with pg_stat_statements preloaded in #11; Nathan traced it to allocation in the unavailable PostmasterContext and also identified the list's allocation-context problem in #12.
- Nathan supplied the memory-context fix in #13, Heikki approved it in #14, and Nathan handed off committing in #15; Heikki landed the attachment unchanged as 2407c8db15 and confirmed completion in #16.
- After Sami's reminder in #17, Heikki landed the remaining MainLWLockArray comment correction from #10 with shorter wording as bd365b1ae5 and confirmed it in #18.
- By the final confirmation in #18, all attached changes had landed, including the single-user regression fix; the broader API-renaming discussion from #4, #5, and #7 had produced no attached or committed rename in this thread.