CLUSTER equivalent

Started by Kevin Murphyover 20 years ago2 messagesgeneral
Jump to latest
#1Kevin Murphy
murphy@genome.chop.edu

Are the two following options equivalent?

OPTION A (ordered insert):

CREATE TABLE table1 (cluster_col TEXT, col2 INTEGER);
CREATE INDEX idx1 ON table1(cluster_col);
INSERT INTO table1 (cluster_col, col2) SELECT cluster_col, col2 FROM
table1 ORDER BY cluster_col;

OPTION B (unordered insert followed by CLUSTER):

CREATE TABLE table1 (cluster_col TEXT, col2 INTEGER);
CREATE INDEX idx1 ON table1(cluster_col);
INSERT INTO table1 (cluster_col, col2) SELECT cluster_col, col2 FROM table1;
CLUSTER idx1 ON table1;

Thanks,
Kevin Murphy

P.S. On another topic, did I gather correctly from a recent thread that
it would be more efficient to define the above table (if it were really
only two columns) as:

create table clustered_tagged_genes (integer pmid, text mention);

i.e., with the integer field before the text field?

#2Tom Lane
tgl@sss.pgh.pa.us
In reply to: Kevin Murphy (#1)
Re: CLUSTER equivalent

Kevin Murphy <murphy@genome.chop.edu> writes:

Are the two following options equivalent?
OPTION A (ordered insert):

CREATE TABLE table1 (cluster_col TEXT, col2 INTEGER);
CREATE INDEX idx1 ON table1(cluster_col);
INSERT INTO table1 (cluster_col, col2) SELECT cluster_col, col2 FROM
table1 ORDER BY cluster_col;

OPTION B (unordered insert followed by CLUSTER):

CREATE TABLE table1 (cluster_col TEXT, col2 INTEGER);
CREATE INDEX idx1 ON table1(cluster_col);
INSERT INTO table1 (cluster_col, col2) SELECT cluster_col, col2 FROM table1;
CLUSTER idx1 ON table1;

Pretty much, but the first is probably faster. CLUSTER is not the
speediest possible way of sorting data :-(

P.S. On another topic, did I gather correctly from a recent thread that
it would be more efficient to define the above table (if it were really
only two columns) as:

create table clustered_tagged_genes (integer pmid, text mention);

i.e., with the integer field before the text field?

Yeah, putting fixed-width fields first is usually a (marginal) win.

regards, tom lane