BUG #3914: Self-Join Group-By Clause Produces Incorrect Results
The following bug has been logged online:
Bug reference: 3914
Logged by: Marcus Torres
Email address: marcsf23@yahoo.com
PostgreSQL version: 8.19
Operating system: Linux - Ubuntu
Description: Self-Join Group-By Clause Produces Incorrect Results
Details:
I wrote a simply self-join query to sum the transaction count of different
types of records in a audit table and the result set for the different sum
totals was the same, which is highly incorrect. If I copy the same records
from t_audit to another table and run the same query which is not a
self-join, it works....very strange
Query:
select a1.audit_julian_date AS DATE,
t.cont_pol_name as CONT_POLICY,
sum(a1.txn_count) as CONTENT_COUNT1,
sum(a2.txn_count) as CONTENT_COUNT2
from t_audit a1,
t_audit a2,
tmp_cp_ref t
where t.cont_exp_id = a1.txn_ent_id
and t.cont_exp_id = a2.txn_ent_id
and a1.txn_ent_id = a2.txn_ent_id
and a1.audit_julian_date = a2.audit_julian_date
and a1.audit_type_code = 'CONTENT_1'
and a1.audit_julian_date >= 2454476
and a2.audit_type_code = 'CONTENT_2'
and a2.audit_julian_date >= 2454476
GROUP BY a1.audit_julian_date, t.cont_pol_name
DATE CONT_POLICY CONTENT_COUNT1 CONTENT_COUNT2
------------------------------------------------------
2454483|CP1|6|6
2454484|CP1|143,480|143,480
2454485|CP1|137,133|137,133
2454487|CP1|30,036|30,036
2454488|CP1|889,344|889,344
2454489|CP1|735,556|735,556
2454492|CP1|271,572|271,572
2454493|CP1|719,496|719,496
2454494|CP1|306,867|306,867
2454495|CP1|530,868|530,868
"Marcus Torres" <marcsf23@yahoo.com> writes:
I wrote a simply self-join query to sum the transaction count of different
types of records in a audit table and the result set for the different sum
totals was the same, which is highly incorrect.
You have provided no evidence whatsoever that this output is incorrect.
If you think there's really a bug here, we need a *self contained*
test case.
regards, tom lane