postgres reorders expressions when inlining

Started by Floris Van Neeover 3 years ago3 messagesbugs
Jump to latest
#1Floris Van Nee
florisvannee@Optiver.com

Hi hackers,

I recently ran into some behavior with inlining that seemed strange to me. I managed to break it down into a small reproducible example that I've added. I originally ran into it in more complicated queries that involved inlining of SQL functions instead of subqueries, but it reproduces with subqueries too so that's the example I've added. Tested on v15.

create table t1 as select a, b from generate_series(0, 5) a, generate_series(0, 10) b;
select * from (
select a, b, c
from t1
left join lateral
(
select 1 / b as c
) c on true
where b <> 0
) as o
where o.c is not null

The SELECT query leads to a division by zero. Plan:

Seq Scan on t1
Filter: (((1 / b) IS NOT NULL) AND (b <> 0))

Postgres seems to decide that it's smart to execute the "o.c is not null" check before checking if b is 0. However, this obviously leads to division by 0. In many other cases (for example not using left join lateral but instead putting the calculation straight into the SELECT of the subquery), Postgres does the right thing and checks for 0 first. Also, forcefully disabling inlining (by adding "offset 0" to the subquery for example) makes the query execute correctly.

Is it expected that Postgres reorders these expressions? I'd think that, even though Postgres decides to inline a query, it should at least evaluate the expressions of the inner-part before the outer part to avoid the division by zero.

-Floris

#2David G. Johnston
david.g.johnston@gmail.com
In reply to: Floris Van Nee (#1)
Re: postgres reorders expressions when inlining

On Thursday, December 29, 2022, Floris Van Nee <florisvannee@optiver.com>
wrote:

Is it expected that Postgres reorders these expressions? I'd think that,
even though Postgres decides to inline a query, it should at least evaluate
the expressions of the inner-part before the outer part to avoid the
division by zero.

Yes, this is working as intended, expression order is not something that is
recognized by the system . In this case protect your division with a case
expression.

David J.

#3Tom Lane
tgl@sss.pgh.pa.us
In reply to: Floris Van Nee (#1)
Re: postgres reorders expressions when inlining

Floris Van Nee <florisvannee@Optiver.com> writes:

I recently ran into some behavior with inlining that seemed strange to me. I managed to break it down into a small reproducible example that I've added. I originally ran into it in more complicated queries that involved inlining of SQL functions instead of subqueries, but it reproduces with subqueries too so that's the example I've added. Tested on v15.

create table t1 as select a, b from generate_series(0, 5) a, generate_series(0, 10) b;
select * from (
select a, b, c
from t1
left join lateral
(
select 1 / b as c
) c on true
where b <> 0
) as o
where o.c is not null

The SELECT query leads to a division by zero. Plan:

This is not a bug. We make no ordering guarantees about WHERE clause
execution; if we did, it would cripple the planner's ability to
optimize.

regards, tom lane