interesting! a sequence clashes with data already in that table

Started by Miles Keatonover 21 years ago2 messagesgeneral
Jump to latest
#1Miles Keaton
mileskeaton@gmail.com

Here's an interesting problem!

When a sequence clashes with data already in that table:

CREATE TABLE clients (
id serial NOT NULL PRIMARY KEY UNIQUE,
name varchar(64));

-- import OLD clients, with their original ID#...
INSERT INTO clients VALUES (3, 'Dave');
INSERT INTO clients VALUES (4, 'Sally');

-- done! let the world add new clients now

INSERT INTO clients (name) VALUES ('Harry');
-- no problems, id=1
INSERT INTO clients (name) VALUES ('Mary');
-- no problems, id=2
INSERT INTO clients (name) VALUES ('Burt');
ERROR: duplicate key violates unique constraint "clients_pkey"

I thought Postgres would be smart enough to make the clients_id_seq
skip existing numbers, but I guess not!

Do I, instead, have to be smart enough to set the sequence over the
highest existing id# from my imported data, so that it can blindly
increment without clashing?

If so, setval() would be best for that, right?

#2Bruno Wolff III
bruno@wolff.to
In reply to: Miles Keaton (#1)
Re: interesting! a sequence clashes with data already in that table

On Fri, Oct 08, 2004 at 03:00:07 -0700,
Miles Keaton <mileskeaton@gmail.com> wrote:

I thought Postgres would be smart enough to make the clients_id_seq
skip existing numbers, but I guess not!

It wouldn't be very efficient to do that.

Do I, instead, have to be smart enough to set the sequence over the
highest existing id# from my imported data, so that it can blindly
increment without clashing?

That is normally what you want to do.

If so, setval() would be best for that, right?

Yes.